Make that Four Boards to watch in full

In early January, we listed five boards to watch in full. See post: http://povblogger.blogspot.com/2009/01/5-boards-to-watch-in-full.html

Now that one of them, GM, has been involuntarily forced to replace their CEO, we're down to four.

When and where will the next shoe drop? Stay tuned. While currently flat, high profile turnover will increase in the months ahead. If it doesn't, well then we're looking at newer heights to the status quo. Or lows, depending on your point of view.

# # #

Undeniable truth

Following is reprinted from our client newsletter, "The Pointe." Based on the high direct response rate, we're posting a copy to share more widely. Thanks for continuing to read, JG.

======================================

Lost within the AIG bonus and big banking mess lies an undeniable truth. You can't dictate proper behavior.

Rules don't create an incentive to do things. Penalties provide a deterrent but only when enforced, which hasn't been the case for a while now. Rules or laws create boundaries, which lead to limits, which have been extended now more than ever by a system that many believe to be gamed to benefit the rich and powerful. When those limits cross the highly discretionary line of good vs. bad, well, you get outrage -- followed by dust-ups -- followed by settling -- followed by more of the same with the cycle repeating over and over.

More often than not, rules create a set of unintended consequences that fall so far outside the lines that we're left scratching our heads as to why. Enter the highly charged pinata issue called executive pay. Whether it's a deified CEO or his/her underlings, outrage over excessive compensation has no limit. Yet every time the government offers up a new rule or reform, you can almost see bands of brothers heading underground to devise new ways around the rules.

Compounding this situation are so called leaders who feel the need to impose their will on others vs. doing the hard work that they should be doing: Aligning beliefs and values of diverse constituencies to create better modes of behavior. We could throw the whole lot of politicians and their appointees in this pool and try to drown them, but that seems a little over the top. They think more laws and regulations are the fix when history shows that approach rarely works. Dov Seidman, author of "How", sums it up this way: "Laws tell you what you can do. Values inspire in you what you should do."

Back to Earth, or Main Street. It's a leadership responsibility to model proper behavior within our companies and organizations. Simple enough, right? Well, not exactly. But it's generally where the buck starts and stops -- not whether another policy can be jammed down people's throats.

# # #

Revamp to Nowhere

So Citigroup is revamping its board under the direction of change agent, Chairman Richard Parsons. Yawn. Stretch. Rub those eyes.

Here's our slate of nominees, which we thoroughly researched and arrived at after careful contemplation. Or as much as Spencer Stuart will likely do over the next six months while they collect a handsome fee talking to the same old recycled hands. In fairness to Spencer Stuart, any of the other old line firms would be handling the search in the same way.

We don't the buy the idea that no one will want to serve on this board despite the potential pitfalls. Mainly due to what a Search master always says, "we never have trouble finding candidates for major CEO and board positions."

Paula Rosput Reynolds -- Fresh off her AIG and Delta stints, there is no one more primed and ready for for more board responsibility when it comes to potential turnarounds, sales and/or bankruptcies.
Bob Nardelli -- Proven bag carrier for private equity, strong operations experience and can ask for the loan/sale, a competency which Citi's board will need. And while he's a sitting CEO, Nardelli isn't exactly leading explosive growth right now so he should have plenty of time to lend expertise to a national cause.
Jeffrey Immelt -- Why not? After overseeing GE Capital's debacle, he ought to know how to avoid future mine fields. For those who say he has hands full right now, well, not for long if that stock continues its decline into value meal territory.
Pete Correll -- Last great company CEO to take a large operation private without losing their shirt (Georgia-Pacific Corp. sold to Koch Industries in 2006)
Ken Chenault -- Primed and ready after steering the ship quietly away from ice bergs at American Express, a proven financial services company. They're always Open, right?
Paul O'Neil -- former Treasury Secretary under George W. Bush and retired CEO of Alcoa. Government will need someone who knows all the pitfalls -- besides, it's time to throw the Republicans a bone in the spirit of partisanship.

Alternates: Assuming some members of the above slate aren't available, we also would like to suggest John Snow based on the svelte handling of the Cerebrus/Chrysler bailout and Dick Grasso for his expertise on lucrative pay packages awarded right under the nose of compensation committees.

Throw in a few of the previously publicly named suspects from the banking industry, and voila, you have a whole new slate ready to steer Citi back to...who knows. Either they're going away, will live to another day or be run as a quasi-private enterprise by the government. Here's what we do know: No one really knows. Or if they do, nobody is telling the public.

# # #